From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (2024)

No matter the technique or flavoring, these roast, grilled, and smoked variations on Thanksgiving turkey are guaranteed to deliver a show-stopping entree for your holiday feast.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (1)

Courtesy The Joy of Cooking

It’s hard to imagine Thanksgiving without a good turkey. The stuffing and the potatoes and the green beans all may flesh out the meal. But the focus is on the bird. With that level of importance, you need to have a good recipe.

However you like your turkey prepared, you’ve got plenty of options to help either stick to tradition or try something new. For fans of a classic roast turkey, why not mix things up a little by making it in the style of the traditional Italian pork roast, porchetta? Or pay homage to the flavor of SoCal with a citrus and herb-infused Ojai-inspired roast turkey.

Or if you prefer a grilled turkey, try giving it a boost of fresh flavors with a celery herb rub. Or instead, why not add a little kick, with a chile and spice rub.

More Videos From Sunset

And for those who prefer not to take up their whole oven with one bird, there are plenty of smoked turkey recipes out there as well. Take a trip deep into the Pacific with a Hawaiian-inspired turkey marinated in soy sauce and ginger, or bring the flavors of your glass to life in the bird with a wine-smoked turkey.

Whatever recipe you choose, make sure you’ve got a gravy recipe that’ll stand up to and improve upon your turkey. And of course, you need all the right gear to properly make a great turkey. Our selection of turkey prep tools will save you from being poorly equipped for the big meal.

  • Roast Turkey Recipes
  • Grilled and Smoked Turkey Recipes
  • Gravy Recipes
  • Essential Thanksgiving Tools

Roast Turkey Recipes

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (2)

1 of 8Courtesy The Joy of Cooking

Joy of Cooking’s Classic Roast Turkey

A perfectly browned, supremely moist turkey takes the spotlight of any traditional Thanksgiving spread. This recipe forClassic Roast Turkeyfrom the latest edition ofJoy of Cooking, originally written by now-iconic American home chef Irma S. Rombauer, does just that.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (3)

2 of 8Thomas J. Story

Dry-Cured Roasted Turkey with Herb Butter

Rubbing turkey with salt 2 days before roasting seasons it well without themessiness of a brine, and a flavorful herbbutter adds juiciness.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (4)

3 of 8Heather Arndt Anderson

Classic Roast Turkey

This is far and away our most popular turkey recipe—try it and find out why!

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (5)

4 of 8Thomas J. Story

Porchetta-Style Roast Turkey

Stuffed with an herb paste, rolled, tied, and baked until golden, this succulent roast is the polar opposite of overcooked, bland turkey breast. It was inspired by the Italian pork roast called porchetta, traditionally seasoned with garlic, red chile, and aromatic fennel.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (6)

5 of 8Yunhee Kim

Heritage Turkey with Crisped Pancetta and Rosemary

Is this your year to try a heritage turkey? Many people favor them over standard grocery store birds for their deep flavor, but they do require careful cooking to be tender.

6 of 8James Carrier

Ojai Roast Turkey with Rosemary, Lemon, and Garlic

This turkey’s sunny Southern California flavors of citrus, herbs, and garlic are always a hit.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (8)

7 of 8Lisa Romerein

Guajillo-Tamarind Turkey

Cook gently spicy guajillo chiles with tart-fruity tamarind, roasted garlic, honey, and lime to create an outstanding Mexican-style glaze for your holiday bird.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (9)

8 of 8Jim Henkens

Juniper-and-Herb Roast Turkey

Pre-salting the Thanksgiving turkey—not to mention covering the breast and drumsticks with bacon—adds flavor and helps it stay moist during roasting.

Grilled and Smoked Turkey Recipes

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (10)

1 of 9Romulo Yanes

Grilled Butterflied Turkey

For juicy, crisp-skinned, evenly cooked turkey, you can do no better than a butterflied (spatchco*cked) bird.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (11)

2 of 9Romulo Yanes

Grilled Butterflied Turkey with Celery Herb Rub

An aromatic rub of fresh celery leaves, plus bold fresh herbs and black pepper, give this turkey a flavor boost.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (12)

3 of 9Romulo Yanes

Grilled Butterflied Turkey with Fennel Garlic Rub

That secret ingredient in Italian sausage—fennel—transforms turkey into a main course that summons up the allure of the Mediterranean.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (13)

4 of 9Thomas J. Story

Grilled Butterflied Turkey with Rosemary Garlic Gravy

Butterflying the turkey—removing the back so it lies flat—makes it cook faster and more evenly.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (14)

5 of 9Annabelle Breakey

Sage and Thyme Smoked Turkey

The Thanksgiving bird takes on a whole new flavor. It just might become your holiday tradition. We created this juicy, fragrant bird flavored with herbs and apple­wood smoke.

6 of 9Leigh Beisch

Wine-Smoked Turkey

Smoking turkey on the grill with wine-infused wood chips gives the bird lots of flavor and provides extra oven space.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (16)

7 of 9Shelly Strazis

Chile and Spice Grilled Turkey with Mole Gravy

A chile-rubbed bird cooked on the grill and served withmolegravy makes for a richly seasoned dinner.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (17)

8 of 9Lisa Romerein

Hawaiian-Portuguese Smoked Turkey

For a Hawaiian take on Thanksgiving, marinate turkey with soy sauce, ginger, garlic, vinegar, and brown sugar.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (18)

9 of 9Courtesy of Matt Horn

Matt Horn’s Smoked Turkey Legs

Turkey is not just for large gatherings, served as a whole bird, pitmaster Matt Horn says. Breasts can be smoked for a weeknight dinner. Here we use legs—the dark meat is juicer, more flavorful, and less expensive than the white meat. This recipe makes a lot of turkey. If you don’t need as much, just cut the recipe in half.This recipe comes from Matt Horn’s cookbook (his first!),Horn Barbecue: Recipes and Techniques from a Master of the Art of BBQ.

Turkey Gravy Recipes

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (19)

1 of 3

Classic Gravy

An easy version of the giblet gravy Grandma used to make, this cornstarch-thickened favorite is made by using turkey necks, giblets, carrots, celery, and onions to enhance store-bought chicken stock. Giblets can be strained out of the stock or chopped up into the finished gravy.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (20)

2 of 3Thomas J. Story

Roasted Turkey Gravy

RoastedThanksgiving vegetablesand drippings from the turkey pan, plus toasted roux for thickening, make for a deeply flavored gravy.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (21)

3 of 3Romulo Yanes

Make-Ahead White Wine Gravy

This recipe takes the last-minute hassle out of gravy making by not relying on pan drippings. Before browning the flour, have the broth measured so you can whisk it in at just the right moment.

We only recommend things we love. If you buy something through our site, we might earn a commission.

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (22)

1 of 7Courtesy of Made In Cookware

Made In Cookware’s Blue Carbon Steel Roasting Pan

Cheaper than the competition and induction-burner-compatible.

Made In Cookware's Blue Carbon Steel Roasting Pan, $139

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (23)

2 of 7Courtesy of Willams Sonoma

Shun Classic Blonde 8-Inch Chef’s Knife

Don’t bother with the single-purpose carving knife. Buy this chic, blonde, Pakawood-handled, Japanese-made chef’s knife that’s got all the ceremonial swagger but year-round usefulness.

Shun Classic Blonde 8-Inch Chef's Knife, $180

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (24)

3 of 7Courtesy of Sur la Table

John Boos Cutting Board

You’re going need that little juice groove. Made of antimicrobial maple, it’s handsome enough to use as a rustic serving platter.

John Boos Cutting Board, $110

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (25)

4 of 7Courtesy of Filson

Filson Tin Cloth Apron

Sturdy and large enough to protect you from errant cranberry juice, spattering turkey fat, and spilled Pinot Noir.

Filson Tin Cloth Apron, $125

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (26)

5 of 7Courtesy of OXO

OXO 9-Inch Pie Plate with Lid

Slightly deeper than competition, this updated version of the classic glass pie plate also comes with a handy domed lid that’ll protect even the loftiest cream pies.

OXO 9-Inch Pie Plate with Lid, $15

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (27)

6 of 7Courtesy of Amazon

OXO Good Grips 4-Cup Fat Separator

Gotta love a fat separator for easily discarding the lipids while tidily reserving the drippings (which have about 10 times the flavor of the turkey itself). Plus it doubles as a measuring pitcher you can use the rest of the year.

OXO Good Grips 4-Cup Fat Separator, $33

From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (28)

7 of 7Courtesy of Anthropologie

How to Style Your Thanksgiving Table

The finishing touch your Thanksgiving feast needs might not be another pie—it might be one of these stylish and functional accessories.

Search All of Sunset’s Recipes

Endive with Beet Vinaigrette and Salsa HungaraBy Nicole Clausing
Charred Onion Labneh with Smoked Trout RoeBy Nicole Clausing
By Nicole Clausing
Keep Reading:
  • family meals
  • Holidays
  • Thanksgiving
  • turkey
From Classic to Unexpected, These Thanksgiving Turkey Recipes Are Total Winners (2024)

FAQs

What percent of Americans do not eat turkey on Thanksgiving? ›

The National Turkey Federation reports that approximately 88 percent of Americans consume turkey on Thanksgiving, translating to over 46 million turkeys eaten on the fourth Thursday in November.

How many turkeys are prepared in America each year for Thanksgiving? ›

According to the National Turkey Federation, an estimated 88 percent of Americans consume Thanksgiving turkey each year. Per the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), this translates to more than 46 million turkeys eaten on Thanksgiving.

When did turkey become the traditional Thanksgiving dinner? ›

As Thanksgiving Day rose in popularity during the 1800s, so too did the turkey. By 1857, turkey had become part of the traditional dinner in New England. The domestic turkey eaten now is very different from the wild turkey known to the Pilgrims, Hamilton, and Franklin.

Which state eats the most turkey on Thanksgiving? ›

Of all the states, residents of California consume the most turkey per person, but California is not one of the five. Missouri is. It's number five. The top turkey producing state is Minnesota, followed by North Carolina, Arkansas and Virginia.

What percent of Americans skip turkey? ›

When going in for seconds, two-thirds of Americans are getting sides (66 percent) rather than the turkey, including an overwhelming majority of Gen Z (76 percent), and women (73 percent). More than half of Americans (57 percent) would rather a guest show up empty-handed than with a side dish that nobody likes.

How many people eat chicken instead of turkey for Thanksgiving? ›

The fascinating new statistic emerged in a new survey of 2,000 Americans around all things concerning Thanksgiving, which also crowned ham (60 percent), chicken (41 percent) and roast beef (37 percent) as the most popular alternatives to turkey.

What did they eat for Thanksgiving before turkey? ›

But according to the two only remaining historical records of the first Thanksgiving menu, that meal consisted of freshly killed deer, assorted wildfowl, cod, bass, and flint, and a native variety of corn harvested by the Native Americans, which was eaten as corn bread and porridge.

What was the original Thanksgiving dinner? ›

So, to the question “What did the Pilgrims eat for Thanksgiving,” the answer is both surprising and expected. Turkey (probably), venison, seafood, and all of the vegetables that they had planted and harvested that year—onions, carrots, beans, spinach, lettuce, and other greens.

What meat was used instead of turkey at the first Thanksgiving? ›

Although turkeys were indigenous, there's no record of a big, roasted bird at the feast. The Wampanoag brought deer and there would have been lots of local seafood (mussels, lobster, bass) plus the fruits of the first pilgrim harvest, including pumpkin. No mashed potatoes, though.

What is a female turkey called? ›

Adult female turkeys are called hens. Juvenile females are called jennies. Adult females average half the size of male turkeys.

Which president made Thanksgiving a permanent national holiday? ›

Later, President Abraham Lincoln took steps towards designating it a permanent federal holiday. Americans traditionally recognize the "first" Thanksgiving as having taken place at Plymouth colony in the autumn of 1621.

Can wild turkeys fly? ›

Wild turkeys can fly and have a top flight speed of about 55 miles per hour. Wild turkeys see in color and have excellent daytime vision, three times better than a human's eyesight, with a visual field of more than 270 degrees.

What percentage of people like turkey on Thanksgiving? ›

About 3 in 10 U.S. adults (32%) who will celebrate Thanksgiving this year say turkey is their favorite dish in the holiday feast, according to a new poll from The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research.

Why do some people not eat turkey on Thanksgiving? ›

Nearly All U.S. Turkeys Are Raised on Factory Farms

Each year, more than 200 million turkeys are slaughtered for food in the U.S. — and over 99 percent of U.S. turkeys are raised on industrial farms and kept in severely crowded and unsanitary conditions.

What food do more than 90 percent of Americans eat on Thanksgiving? ›

MINNEAPOLIS (WCCO) - Almost 90 percent of Americans will eat turkey for Thanksgiving, according to the National Turkey Federation.

Do people still eat turkey on Thanksgiving? ›

Almost all had the same answer when asked why we eat turkey on Thanksgiving. They either mentioned tradition or simply said, "because it's what we always ate on that day." And despite turkey's setbacks, such as getting too dry or lacking flavor, families continue plating the big bird on Thanksgiving.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Velia Krajcik

Last Updated:

Views: 5904

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (74 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Velia Krajcik

Birthday: 1996-07-27

Address: 520 Balistreri Mount, South Armand, OR 60528

Phone: +466880739437

Job: Future Retail Associate

Hobby: Polo, Scouting, Worldbuilding, Cosplaying, Photography, Rowing, Nordic skating

Introduction: My name is Velia Krajcik, I am a handsome, clean, lucky, gleaming, magnificent, proud, glorious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.