12 Sweet Peeps Recipes That Use Up Leftover Easter Candy (2024)

The best thing about Easter as a kid was the numerous packages of pastel sugar-coated marshmallow goodness that arrived in our baskets without fail. Peeps are an Easter candy tradition, so they obviously deserve a place on your table this year.

You're already going to wow the family with Easter brunch, so why not use up your Easter basket bounty with colorful Peeps recipes and desserts? These 12 sweet Peeps recipes are chocolatey, gooey and crispy (there may even be an Easter co*cktail involved!), and they're absolutely perfect for fueling your post-Easter dinner sweet tooth.

12 Sweet Peeps Recipes That Use Up Leftover Easter Candy (1)

Peeps Skillet Dip

If you know someone who doesn't love Peeps, make this for them and they'll definitely be a convert. It's just about the most fun way to get everyone around the table together! (via Brit + Co)

12 Sweet Peeps Recipes That Use Up Leftover Easter Candy (2)

Peeps Rice Krispies Eggs

Taking the time to mold your Rice Krispies in plastic eggs is well worth the extra time. When a Peeps recipe is this easy, there's no reason not to take the cute factor up a notch! (via Brit + Co)

12 Sweet Peeps Recipes That Use Up Leftover Easter Candy (3)

Peeps S'mores

These s'more sandwiches are just about one of the cutest Peeps recipes we've ever seen! Dip the graham crackers in chocolate and sprinkles for an even more festive look. (via Brit + Co)

12 Sweet Peeps Recipes That Use Up Leftover Easter Candy (4)

Peeps Rice Krispies Treats

Pre-packaged Rice Krispies treats make quick work of these candy-coated pops! Slice your Peeps in half lengthwise so you can see them on both sides. (via Love from the Oven)

12 Sweet Peeps Recipes That Use Up Leftover Easter Candy (5)

Peeps Sunflower Brownies

There's absolutely no way you could be unhappy looking at a Peeps sunflower brownie! You can arrange your yellow Peeps as shown, or upside down if you prefer. Varying the size of the chocolate chips in the middle gives the effect of real sunflower seeds. Adorable! (via The Semisweet Sisters)

12 Sweet Peeps Recipes That Use Up Leftover Easter Candy (6)

Peeps Pizza

Attention, all marshmallow lovers! This dessert pizza has marshmallows in the pizza crust as well as a marshmallow frosting on top. Of course, it's decorated with marshmallow Peeps, too. (via Baking Beauty)

12 Sweet Peeps Recipes That Use Up Leftover Easter Candy (7)

Marshmallow Peeps Lemon Drops Martini

It may seem counterintuitive, but this drink with a Peeps floating in it is for adults only. Peeps-infused vodka is the star of this unique martini recipe, and you'll definitely want to keep some on-hand from now on. (via Sew You Think You Can Cook)

12 Sweet Peeps Recipes That Use Up Leftover Easter Candy (8)

Easter Peeps Cake

If you want a true sugar overload from this year's Peeps recipes, opt for this sweet cake. It's covered in the marshmallow treats for a colorful, Insta-worthy effect, too! (via Kathryn's Kitchen)

12 Sweet Peeps Recipes That Use Up Leftover Easter Candy (9)

Easter Peep-Za

If only all dessert pizzas could have a sugar cookie crust and chocolate ganache sauce. A peanut topping adds a salty element to this otherwise very sweet Easter pizza. Your Peeps will surely volunteer to grace the top of this dessert. (via The Cooking Channel)

12 Sweet Peeps Recipes That Use Up Leftover Easter Candy (10)

3-Layer Angel Food Peeps Cake

If a light-as-air cake covered in buttercream is your thing, than you need to run to the kitchen to make this immediately. Just beware of the Peeps bunnies that are standing guard — they're more vicious than they look. (via The Farmer's Daughter)

12 Sweet Peeps Recipes That Use Up Leftover Easter Candy (11)

Peeps Monster Cookies

These giant flourless cookies are packed with peanut butter and candy — pretty much what dreams are made of! Stick two cookies together with warm Peeps in the middle, and all of your cookie s'mores dreams will come true. (via Southern Fatty)

12 Sweet Peeps Recipes That Use Up Leftover Easter Candy (12)

Easter Peeps Cookie Butter Cups

These Peeps may think they just got stuck in a mud puddle, but really, it's just chocolate and creamy cookie butter. They also don't know they're about to be devoured. Poor little guys! (via Knead to Cook)

Follow us on Pinterest for more easy + delicious recipe ideas!

This post has been updated with additional reporting by Meredith Holser.

From Your Site Articles

  • This Funfetti Sugar Cookie Recipe Will Complete Every Easter Basket ›
  • Get the Easter Party Started With Peeps Skillet Dip ›
  • How to Make Easy, Last Minute Peeps Rice Krispies Eggs ›
  • How to Make DIY Cactus Peeps for Easter - Brit + Co ›
  • How to make easter peeps fruit kabobs - B+C Guides ›
  • How to make peeps hot cocoa - B+C Guides ›
  • Bring Down the House This Easter With a Peeps Piñata - Brit + Co ›
  • 20 Adorable Easter Peeps DIYs for Kids - Brit + Co ›
  • This Is the Most Delicious Way to Eat S'Mores EVER - Brit + Co ›
  • 12 Cute Easter Desserts - Brit + Co ›

Paige Johnson

Paige is a blogger, food writer and culinary master from Louisville, Ky. She's a newlywed who's obsessed with dogs and renovating her 117 year old home. When she's not working on her blog — My Modern Cookery — you can find her binge watching F.R.I.E.N.D.S with a triple shot latte in-hand.

12 Sweet Peeps Recipes That Use Up Leftover Easter Candy (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Francesca Jacobs Ret

Last Updated:

Views: 5901

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (48 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Francesca Jacobs Ret

Birthday: 1996-12-09

Address: Apt. 141 1406 Mitch Summit, New Teganshire, UT 82655-0699

Phone: +2296092334654

Job: Technology Architect

Hobby: Snowboarding, Scouting, Foreign language learning, Dowsing, Baton twirling, Sculpting, Cabaret

Introduction: My name is Francesca Jacobs Ret, I am a innocent, super, beautiful, charming, lucky, gentle, clever person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.